Monday, April 11, 2016

Review: Passenger by Alexandra Bracken

Title: Passenger (Passenger, #1)

Author: Alexandra Bracken

Rating: 3 Stars

I fell in love with Alexandra Bracken's debut when I first read it. So much so that I returned it to the library only to check it out a few months later for a re-read and continued on this path until I eventually forced my local Barnes and Noble to order a copy for me and bought it. It's a gorgeous little paperback that still brings me an inordinate amount of joy.

Needless to say, I was expecting great things from Passenger. Despite not having read The Darkest Minds, I knew enough from reviewers that it had been well-liked and I was confident that Bracken's latest would be nothing short of brilliant.

In some ways, it is.

Passenger is about a young violin prodigy named Etta. Growing up with her single-mother, Rose, and violin instructor, Alice, it has been Etta's dream to become a professional violin player. When a performance at the Met goes tragically wrong, however, she is dragged back in time to 1776 by a stranger named Sophia Ironwood. The Ironwoods are one of the last remaining families of time travelers and, according to them, Etta's mother stole an important artifact from them seventeen years ago and went into hiding. Now that they've found her, they're holding Rose hostage until Etta can find the astrolabe and return it to the Ironwoods, all within a span of days.

I am always bowled over by the unique premises of Bracken's work. We haven't encountered a world quite like Passenger in YA fiction and I don't know why. It is a rich, well-developed concept that I thoroughly enjoyed, especially as the introduction of new information was timed perfectly and never felt too much like an info-dump.

What's more, I really appreciate that Bracken took the effort to discuss meaningful issues in her exploration of history and the strides we have since made--or failed to make. Sophia, for instance, is shocked by the freedoms that Etta takes for granted in the 21st century and struggles, throughout the novel, to find agency in a world that disregards women. Nicholas, the young African American sailor who is  abandoned by the Ironwoods, can't believe in a world where he isn't constantly stared at, scrutinized, or thought to be a slave. When Etta travels to places like Damascus, she's shocked at the thought that modern-day Syria isn't the thriving city she's witnessing from the early 1600s. It's a nod to a multitude of issues that plague us, globally, today and I really appreciated it.

But, I don't think it was enough. I wanted Bracken to do more with this set-up; explore different countries and discuss their history or contrast them more with our modern-day world. I wanted her to tackle issues of cultural appropriation, women's rights in different continents (but not through a lens of white feminism), approach economies and wars from a changed perspective. I wanted her to discuss time on a deeper level--that woozy contradiction between destiny and choice that inevitably arises in a time-travel novel. I just wanted MORE.

More than angst-ridden thoughts from Nicholas's (mostly) unnecessary perspective. More than a romance that seemed a little too convenient, a little too like insta-love for me to fully get behind even though I did begin to warm to this couple on multiple occasions. More than paragraphs I wanted to skim through as these two traveled from place to place and time to time as if pulled along by a string with only a few truly notable thoughts and experiences in each. Most of all, more than another sex-positive YA novel that fails to discuss contraception--hello! I really think Etta might wind up pregnant or with STIs in the sequel! Is no one else worried?--and falls back on common tropes.

Passenger isn't a bad book, by any means. It's unique, compelling, and I really love Etta's voice and character. It's a fascinating approach to time travel and is easy to read and simply fall into. But I definitely wanted more from this story, in many ways, and though I'll probably be reading the sequel, I doubt I'll enjoy it much unless aspects of this story change dramatically to produce a much more mature, thoughtful novel. Definitely recommended, just with reservations--this is one I can see a lot of teens loving but perhaps some readers will be a little disappointed, just as I am.


  1. Great review, Keertana! I'm sorry it didn't quite give you what you wanted though. It has a great premise and it does sound like Bracken could have done and explored some great things. I'm a bit tired of books always needing some big romance, especially ones that feel so much like insta-love.


  2. I enjoyed this one overall Keertana, I liked how the time travel aspect worked and appreciated that she didn't make it so confusing that my head heart trying to understand:)

    I do think it's interesting that contraception is almost NEVER mentioned in paranormal/fantasy YA, whereas in contemporary YA it's typically front and center if sex is a part of the story. Almost like the sex in paranormal/fantasy isn't real because of the genre, so they don't have to be as careful? It's strange, but I agree, even a brief mention of safe sex would have been good:)

  3. "(but not through a lens of white feminism)" Agreed. I don't mind this perspective, but if you are gravitating toward that view (having different cultures in your book) then I would also want that perspective. Always frustrates me because I want that information. I also would have totally loved a book that tackled all the differences in history with those issues. However, the big publishers tend to water that down a lot.

    Also, not happy with the insta love. I think I hate that more than the triangle. Still, overall it does sound like a compelling book... especially since it made you think. :D

  4. My thoughts exactly Keertana. The concept was great, but the execution just doesn't live up to the amazing premise. Sorry to hear you felt a bit ambivalent about it too, but thank you for sharing your thoughts nonetheless. Fabulous review! ♥

  5. I'm sorry that you weren't able to enjoy this one as much as you'd hoped Keertana, I can understand some of the issues that you had too, I for one would definitely want more detail and explanation. But the world that Bracken has set up sounds wonderful, and I'm glad to see that you're not put off reading the next book! Lovely review! And I do highly recommend reading Bracken's Darkest Minds series, its one of my all time favourites!

  6. Oh so glad to see a different review of this book! I've seen nothing but raving reviews and as I've never read anything from this author I just wasn't sure. I thought I must read it because of the reviews but your more temperate review makes me feel like I can wait for the rest of the series. I actually thought it was a stand alone! I hope that your concerns in the first book are explored more in the second book. Very well done review!!

  7. I don't know about this one, Keertana. I am curious about the heroine being a violinist prodigy, but I think this is an instance where I wished she was in another plot altogether. The time traveling thing is just not my idea of a good time. :/

  8. That premise sounds amazing, but...a premise can be amazing and it means nada

  9. Sorry to hear Passenger didn’t live up to your expectations, Keertana. I’m intrigued by this rich and unique world, but I don’t like the sound of the romance. Also many reviewers mentioned that this book is very slow paced. I’m not sure this book is for me, but I’ll check out her debut novel.


I love hearing from my readers and I read, reply, and appreciate every one of the comments I receive!(: If you're a fellow blogger, please leave a link to your blog - I'd love to drop by!

Unfortunately, this is now an award-free blog. I simply do not have the time to respond and forward on the award, but I truly appreciate the nomination regardless.