Monday, April 6, 2015

Mini-Review: The Glass Arrow by Kristen Simmons

Title: The Glass Arrow

Author: Kristen Simmons

Rating: 3.5 Stars
The Handmaid’s Tale meets Blood Red Road in Glass Arrow, the story of Aya, who lives with a small group of women on the run from the men who hunt them, men who want to auction off breeding rights to the highest bidder. In a world where females are scarce and are hunted, then bought and sold at market for their breeding rights, 15-year old Aya has learned how to hide. With a ragtag bunch of other women and girls, she has successfully avoided capture and eked out a nomadic but free existence in the mountains. But when Aya’s luck runs out and she’s caught by a group of businessmen on a hunting expedition, fighting to survive takes on a whole new meaning.
The Glass Arrow is being lauded as a breath of fresh air in the dystopian genre--and, to some extent, I suppose it is. Yet, while Simmons latest is a vast improvement from her debut trilogy (in my opinion, at any rate), I found myself left wanting at the end. Simmons throws us into a futuristic world where the freedoms women have fought so hard to win are, once again, stripped away. In the world of The Glass Arrow, women are auctioned off for their beauty and virginity, the combination proving to be deadly as wealthy merchants, landowners, and politicians seek females in order to extend their line. Aya, our protagonist who has grown up in the wild, free from civilization's constraints, finds herself captured and awaiting to be auctioned. Determined to escape and return to her family, still somewhere in the wilderness, Aya rebels and finds herself thrown time and time again into solitary confinement.

In solitary confinement, Aya befriends Brax, a wolf pup, and Kiran, a Driver. The Drivers are a separate caste, almost, of people who are said to be born mute. Though Kiran doesn't speak, Aya finds herself slowly growing to trust him. As a heroine, Aya is an inspiration. Not only does she shut down, fight against, and correct the notions of the girls around her--beliefs that they hold about their worth as seen through a man's eyes--but she can hold her own both physically and mentally as well. While she's remarkably similar to kick-ass protagonists like Tris or Katniss who care for their family and freedom above all else, the originality of the realm she survives in sets her apart. Aya isn't a difficult character to like and neither is Kiran. Though the Drivers can be dangerous, and Aya suspects Kiran during their initial meetings, the friendship and trust that build between them extend to the reader as well. While Aya is an open book from the first page to the last, Simmons uncovers the layers to Kiran's character slowly, using his mute-ness to create a dynamic between himself and Aya that is wholly unique. Aya and Kiran's romance is subtle--a true back-burner--and though I yearned for more of it, it is nevertheless utterly satisfying.

The Glass Arrow possesses a scintillating plot line, one that shifts from different settings and introduces a fascinating host of secondary characters at every turn. I couldn't predict the outcome of many of the situations Aya was placed in but I found myself emotionally involved and rooting for her throughout. Yet--and perhaps this is because I attend an all-women's college--I wanted The Glass Arrow to take a stronger feminist stance. Aya is seemingly the only female in this world who wants her own rights and freedoms. Moreover, there is little to no political scheme throughout this story though I would love to see this set-up of this future explored in a manner that isn't traditionally dystopian. While Simmons has created a world full of strife, inequality, and injustice, she doesn't use this as a platform to remark on modern-day issues. Or, at any rate, not enough. I expected this to be a larger-than-life tale and though Aya and Kiran's journey is remarkable and touching, it also stays a little too safe, in my eyes. Simmons doesn't challenge her readers to think or question society--it's all quite black-and-white--and I find myself wondering why she chose such a potentially conflicting backdrop if she didn't intend to spark conversation.

Nevertheless, The Glass Arrow is a fast-paced, entertaining dystopia which is guaranteed to garner emotional attachment. While it didn't reach the full potential I hoped for, I'm keeping my fingers crossed that Simmons returns to this world--much like the authors of These Broken Stars--to more carefully remark on other aspects of this universe. For those who believe the dystopian genre has run dry of ideas, The Glass Arrow will prove you wrong.


  1. I love that this is fast paced but leery about reading it since it left you wanting at the end.
    Too bad this didn't blow you away but glad you did at least like it.
    Great honest review!

  2. Slowly wading myself back into blogging, and I'm so glad to be commenting again, although of course, I've stayed updated on all your posts. =)

    Reading the description for this book, I truly thought there would be a lot of parallels drawn to today's world and the stance of women in society, given the nature of this book. I mean, it's a pretty interesting concept after all. So I'm honestly quite surprised that the author holds back a little. I probably would have found that rather disappointing, because this book seems like the PERFECT opportunity to make some dramatic statements. At least I have a heads-up now!

    I also love the way you described the plot line, Keertana! It sounds riveting, and the characters sound absolutely fantastic. I'm liking the sound of the romance, especially because it appears to be so, so unique.

    Gorgeous, gorgeous review as always, girl!! 😄

  3. I missed you and your mini reviews that aren't mini at all! I'll be starting this book in a few days. I expected so much from it, what with all the mentioning of The Handmaid's Tale, and I'm sorry it didn't quite deliver, but I still think I'll enjoy it overall. I can't wait.

  4. Thanks for sharing. I wasn't terribly interested in this one based on the summary, but I appreciate your thoughts. I'm not sure this is the right fit for me! If you try the second in the series, hopefully you like it more.

  5. I've not seen the best reviews of this book, but your review is the most complete. I do think I would also want a more feminist stance and it makes sense given the context. You do have me curious about this one but I know to approach it knowing it won't give me everything I want with the subject matter. Brilly review

  6. I would definitely agree with you in terms of wanting a stronger feminist stance from this novel but at the same time, the reason why I wasn't wholly disappointed in this book was because I feel like it is at least making a point in some ways.

    There are people, aside from Aya, that believe that auctioning women off like they are cattle is wrong, there are protesters within this world and I liked knowing that Aya doesn't just wake up one day and think "OMG this sucks".

    I guess that aspect, since it is so hard to find within the dystopian genre, made up for some of my other minor issues which was why I ended up really loving the novel.

    I am glad that even though you didn't fall in love with this book the way I did, you managed to enjoy it!

    Lovely review, as ALWAYS, Keertana!! :)

    Rashika @ The Social Potato

  7. I haven't read anything by this author yet but I've wanted to for a while. I have Artcile 5 but I have really read it as I'm a bit picky sometimes with dystopias. But I'm glad this one is a lot better and stronger than her previous series. So if I read one her books soon I will start with this one. Great mini review, Keertana.

  8. Lovely review as always, lady! I liked Simmons' first series well enough, but I definitely had my problems with it... so I was hesitant about Glass Arrow but hopeful. It turns out that I really, really loved it. The worldbuilding, the characters, the romance... it was all so wonderful. I especially loved the dynamic between Aya and Driver due to his muteness... I thought that was so well done.

    My biggest complaint is one of yours too - I didn't like that she seemed to be the only girl who stood up for her gender. The "mean girls" in the beginning were just too much, and I wanted more rapport among them. Otherwise, I really, really loved this.

  9. I'm always on the lookout for dystopian books that offer that little bit more and so I'm thrilled to see that The Glass Arrow did. It feels like ages since I read a book with a kick ass heroine, so can't wait to Aya! Fab review! :)

  10. I don't like the premiss of the Handmaiden's tale so any book compared to drives me away. I'm happy to hear you enjoyed the romance even though you wished there was more of it. Lovely review, Keertana. :)

  11. I haven't read this one yet, though it's on my shelf. I'm resisting because of the whole "women are auctioned off for their beauty and virginity" thing. Why is this still such a thing? Alas.

  12. Did you know you can create short links with AdFly and make money from every visit to your shortened urls.


I love hearing from my readers and I read, reply, and appreciate every one of the comments I receive!(: If you're a fellow blogger, please leave a link to your blog - I'd love to drop by!

Unfortunately, this is now an award-free blog. I simply do not have the time to respond and forward on the award, but I truly appreciate the nomination regardless.