Friday, April 11, 2014
ARC Mini-Review: High and Dry by Sarah Skilton
Title: High and Dry
Author: Sarah Skilton
Rating: 3 Stars
Release Date: April 15th, 2014
Following the success of her debut novel, Bruised, Sarah Skilton's sophomore effort, High and Dry left much to be desired. Quite simply put, High and Dry contains one too many plot threads to function efficiently as a cohesive novel. Where Bruised was direct, providing focused insight on the trauma surrounding a young teenage girl, High and Dry follows high school senior Charlie as he tries to win back his ex-girlfriend Ellie, help his other ex-girlfriend find her stolen flash drive, and thwart the authorities who insist on pegging him responsible for causing a classmate to overdose. Although aspects of High and Dry certainly shined, the overall effect of this story was not memorable...to say the least.
As she did with her debut, Skilton proves - once again - to be adept at navigating the tumultuous waters of the teenage mind. Writing from the perspective of a male narrator, she still manages to keep Charlie's voice realistic, witty, and engaging. It's incredible easy to become sucked into Charlie's tale - a definite plus point - and his inner struggles were perfectly portrayed. At the forefront of this novel is the fact that Charlie is still in love with his ex-girlfriend, Ellie, and he's quite sure she's still in love with him too. In the fall, however, Charlie will be attending a nearby university while Ellie is still uncertain about her future. Every moment of their relationship, then, is spent as a ticking time bomb with Charlie firmly believing that Ellie is too good for him and their relationship won't last. Ellie, unable to put up with Charlie's attitude, breaks it off with him only to find him following her diligently, desperately hoping she'll take him back. From my perspective, the entire romantic set-up of High and Dry is original. A male protagonist who feels grounded - anchored, if you will - by his girlfriend, but not to an obsessive or unhealthy extent. Charlie's own insecurities are put to rest due to the knowledge that Ellie picked him. Without Ellie, however, Charlie hardly knows who he is and finds himself struggling to reaffirm his own worth without her approval.
It makes for an intriguing dilemma, to be sure, but one that isn't expanded upon as much as it should be. I found myself wishing that Skilton had chosen to delve deeper into Charlie's psych opposed to his day-to-day actions and interactions; everything inside Charlie's head was far more compelling than anything out of it. Instead, the pace of High and Dry moves quickly, highlighting the multiple action-filled plot threads. While these aspects of the story do come together by the end - with a few surprising plot twists too! - I didn't feel entirely engaged or connected to the Charlie who went out of his way to track down a flash drive. Skilton expertly showcases the multiple facets of Charlie's personality through her complex plot and, by the end of this novel, his growth is truly admirable. Moreover, I absolutely love the slightly open conclusion to this stand-alone, tying together the loose pieces nicely while still leaving room - and hope! - for Charlie's future. Yet, my inability to become entrenched within the fast-moving pace of the bulk of this story made for slow and disappointing reading. While Skilton makes an important statement about teens during this transitional period between childhood (high school) and adulthood (college), High and Dry needed better execution - desperately. Although I certainly wouldn't dissuade readers from giving this one a shot, only because Sarah Skilton wrote it and her characterizations are spot-on, I'd encourage readers new to her work to pick up Bruised first. It doesn't disappoint in the least; trust me.
14 comments:
I love hearing from my readers and I read, reply, and appreciate every one of the comments I receive!(: If you're a fellow blogger, please leave a link to your blog - I'd love to drop by!
Unfortunately, this is now an award-free blog. I simply do not have the time to respond and forward on the award, but I truly appreciate the nomination regardless.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I've heard nothing but good things about Bruised Keertana, so it's a bummer this one didn't quite meet the bar set by it. Too many plot threads is definitely something that keeps me from fully engaging in a story, but I'm glad that Charlie is written so well and she does such a great job writing a male protagonist:)
ReplyDeleteI am feeling very hmm today
ReplyDeleteI still haven't read Bruised and it received really high ratings. I think I will try and meet the author throughout that one rather than this one. High and Dry does sound interesting but like you said I think way too many stuff is going on there. Great review, Keertana :)
ReplyDeleteI haven't read anything by this author. that's great you loved her debut, I'm sorry the second didn't quite live up to expectations. I like that she does a male MC well and that the characterization seems spot on.
ReplyDelete-Lauren
Oh, but it had such an interesting premise. I hate when the book I want to read doesn't live up to the expectations.
ReplyDeleteI'm not a fan of a book with too many plot threads. I usually end up not liking it at all. Still, you have me curious about Bruised! :D
ReplyDeleteMale narrative are so refreshing. Never saw this one before, but it looks good.
ReplyDeletei've seen this author's previous novel bruised a few times but never knew she also wrote this one! i have seen it around the blogosphere a few times but never paid much attention to it. this does sound great--even though it felt cramped with too many plot lines.
ReplyDeletebrilliant review, keertana! <33
While you've certainly made your points why this didn't meet your expectations, I think I'd still like to give this one a chance. I haven't read anything from this author but I think your high opinions of her - regardless of the ho-hum experience - still carry a certain weight.
ReplyDeleteAs usual, a well-thought out, well-written review, Keertana. :)
It's always a shame when an author's next book doesn't live up to your expectations. I am still yet to read Brusied, though I have it and was so excited to read it. I like that Sarah is great at writing for teens, so I'll definitely give this a go, too!
ReplyDeleteI never really liked the premise for this book very much, so I doubt it'll be one that I pick up anytime soon. But I am eager to try Bruised one day - I've heard nothing but fantastic things about it. It's a shame that High and Dry didn't quite live up to your expectations, Keertana, but I'm glad to hear Charlie's voice was a strong point here. It's not often that a male point of view is written well in YA. Thanks for sharing your honest thoughts, as always! Lovely review. :)
ReplyDeleteYou have me more curious about Bruised and there are aspects of this book that appeal to me. It sounds like the idea and talent where there and that the execution failed. Wonderful and thoughtful review Keertana.
ReplyDeleteAwww I'm sorry this one wasn't as impressive a read as Bruised. It doesn't sound like High and Dry is for me, but maybe I'll check out Bruised. Wonderful review as always, Keertana!
ReplyDeleteThank you for reminding me that I need to read Bruised! I'm glad that you were still able to find great points about this novel, including an authentic male voice, but I'm sorry it didn't fully work out for you.
ReplyDelete