Thursday, April 18, 2013

Review: Alif the Unseen by G. Willow Wilson

Title: Alif the Unseen 

Author: G. Willow Wilson 

Rating: 3.5 Stars

Alif the Unseen is one of those obscure novels that not many people have actually heard of, but, thanks to my numerous GoodReads friends who read such varied genres, it somehow came to my attention. Needless to say, all my friends have LOVED this book. For me, though, Alif the Unseen was slightly boring, hard to get through, and dragged ever-so-slightly. I thoroughly enjoyed the second half the book, but I wasn't as impressed as everyone else. While Alif the Unseen remains to be a difficult book for me to categorize, for it is full of so much within its pages, I can most definitely guarantee one thing - you haven't seen anything like it before.

Wilson's debut is the tale of a young hacker, Alif, whose lover, Intisar, refuses to see him again for she is having an arranged marriage to a man of a much higher status than Alif. Upset over his broken love story, Alif creates a software program that recognizes Intisar online and blocks all mention of him from her. Unknowingly, however, the Hand, a powerful organization, finds Alif. At the same time, Intisar sends Alif an old book - a powerful one - and before he knows it, he's on the run with his childhood friend, Dina.

Alif the Unseen is a strange tale, one that just keeps going, without stop. It starts off interestingly enough, drawing you into the rich setting of the Middle East, but before long, it began to drag for me. You see, Alif the Unseen never stops in its pace, which isn't a bad thing, but at times, it felt disjointed. Amongst the action, there are awkward moments of long conversation and the pace suddenly slackens, only to pick up again, all rather suddenly. It was a bit off-putting, I must say, but by the second-half of the tale, I was either used to it or too invested in the story to care. For some reason, the second-half of this story appealed to me much more than the first and I slowly began to fall in love with the characters and the fantasy elements of this piece, all with a backdrop of modern-day Middle Eastern culture and computers.

One of the best elements of Alif the Unseen is, hands-down, the characters. While Alif himself comes across as rather lame at first, especially since we can see from the beginning that Intisar isn't all that great and he's simply infatuated with her, Dina, his childhood friend, is a kick-ass protagonist to contend with. I loved her strong will, vulnerable qualities, and clear head that came in use during times of need. Vikram, a djinn-like creature that Alif winds up meeting, was another one of my favorite characters. Wilson's debut is full of humans, djinns, hackers, and even Americans, believe it or not. With such a wide variety of personalities, it's tough not to be sucked into this tale. Even better, the dialogue is witty, amusing, and will keep you on your toes, eagerly flipping the pages for more.

Nevertheless, for me, Alif the Unseen didn't stand out as an extraordinary novel. Yes, it was good, had an intriguing host of characters, and a unique plot, but it was also a tough story to get through and rather boring at times. But, I am quite sure this is an issue only I will have. Unlike my friends, I have grown up learning of the culture of the Middle East. As an Indian who has many Muslim friends, who has grown up surrounded equally by mosques and temples, who has had Arabian tales told to me by my grandmother, Alif the Unseen wasn't nearly as exotic as I think my other friends found it to be. It didn't enrich my knowledge of the country or culture any more than I already had, thus, while I enjoyed it, I wasn't quite blown away by it either.

Still, an excellent idea, very engaging dialogue, and some unforgettable characters lie within the pages of this book. I am confident that readers who are new to Middle Eastern settings or tales richly seated amongst those of A Thousand and One Nights will thoroughly enjoy and undoubtedly be swept off their feet by this debut. Despite my qualms with it, and slightly indifferent stance towards it, I still cannot help but look forward to Wilson's next novel. If nothing else, here is an author who isn't afraid to help spread the word about a little-known country or culture in literature today and for that, this certainly merits a read.


  1. Oh, I remember Catie's review of this one, and I remember adding it to my tbr pile, but somehow it got buried under the neverending list of books I must read asap. This always happens.
    BUT I don't think I'll be able to resist this setting, and the fabulous characters (especially Dina). Despite a few pacing issues, this seems to be one of those hidden gems I simply can't miss.
    Great review, my darling.

  2. I haven't seen this book before and that's strange. Anyway I'm happy to hear that it's unique but also sad to see that it's boring as well. Maybe I'll read it one day cause I'm really curious about this :) Great review :)

  3. Similar to Maja, this is one that just keep slipping further and further down my TBR pile, despite reading some incredible reviews (yours included!) I'm intrigued by the concept and the idea that this will be just so different to anything else I've read... I should get to it eventually!

  4. You always feature new-to-me books Keertana, I love it! I never know what new and interesting find I'm going to discover when I visit. The pacing sounds a bit tricky to get used to in this one, but I'm glad the characters are so memorable!

  5. I've heard of this one but only vaguely. I'm not sure it's my type of book, but I might check it out. I love the setting and the inclusion of djinns, but I might find the pace just as frustrating as you did. I'm sorry that you didn't enjoy this as much as you hoped, Keertana! Beautiful review btw! :D

  6. This is my first introduction to this book and it sounds like a good one. I don't know much about the Middle East and the muslim culture so I would like to know more. I am all about good characters and plot, I can get beyond a bit of slow pace. I will definitely have to look this one up. Thanks for calling my attention to this one, Keertana!

  7. Good for you for finally posting a review of this one! I...still haven't. >.> Which is a shame because I DID really like it, and I should do my part to get more people aware of it.

    I think you've pegged it, that this was partially so intriguing for me because it was a whole new culture and world that I was pretty much unaware of to this point. I loved Dina and Vikram, and I will say that I think listening to this one on audio improved it for me because the narration really set the scene and was excellent.

  8. I loved this book for more reasons than one. Being Muslim and entirely too self-conscious about it due to current politics, I've often felt that writers either demonize it or preach it. Wilson, on the other hand, does neither. I liked the hint of mythology - djinns are real creatures, I've had experience with some, (hee), and I think Wilson does a great job in bringing to life and showing that there is more to Islam and Muslim culture than terrorism, bombing and cowering. Plus, her own experiences figured in deeply with me. I'm sorry you didn't like it as much you had hoped to.

  9. I don't think the cultural aspects here will feel quite as exotic to me either, but I do like the thought of a slightly different setting. I came across this book on Goodreads, too, but I get the impression that it might not be for me. Lovely review, Keertana!

  10. I have never heard of this book, and you definitely made me take note of it. I love books that take place in the Middle East, especially as I am much less familiar with that area of the world than you are. From your description, I can definitely tell that it's hard to categorize. But it sounds fun, and perhaps knowing that it picks up in the second half would help me stick with it when it drags. Thanks for telling me about this one!

  11. This is a book I keep hearing about as it's the rare fantasy novel that makes literary lists AND written by a woman. But maybe those three things don't make it a perfect read.

    Marlene Detierro (Cash for Gold)


I love hearing from my readers and I read, reply, and appreciate every one of the comments I receive!(: If you're a fellow blogger, please leave a link to your blog - I'd love to drop by!

Unfortunately, this is now an award-free blog. I simply do not have the time to respond and forward on the award, but I truly appreciate the nomination regardless.