Friday, August 3, 2012

Review: Such a Rush by Jennifer Echols


Title: Such a Rush 

Author: Jennifer Echols 

Rating: 2/5 Stars 

I think this is where Jennifer Echols and I go our separate ways. In all honesty, I was totally prepared to do that after reading Forget You, my first novel of hers, but after Going Too Far proved to be slightly better, I had high hopes for this one. Unfortunately, Such a Rush was so riddled with problems that I was left with a bitter taste in my mouth by the end of it.

My problems with Such a Rush started from the beginning of the novel itself - it was slow. Very slow. While I enjoyed seeing how Leah, our protagonist, became a pilot, I found that her narration as a fourteen-year-old and her narration as a seventeen-year-old were not much different. Furthermore, after the death of Mr. Hall, the man who teaches Leah how to fly and becomes a surrogate father to her, she only breaks down and cries once which I found to be highly unrealistic. In fact, I wish Mr. Hall's grief had had a larger impact on Leah herself, opposed to solely having a great impact on his son. Leah was practically a daughter to Mr. Hall and as Leah herself doesn't have a father, I wish her pain and confusion over his death could have been more palpable. If nothing else, I definitely feel as if it would have helped me to understand Leah, a character I found very difficult to connect with, much easier.

Yet, those qualms are easy to overlook in light of what happens next. With Mr. Hall's death, his two sons, Grayson and Alec, proceed to take over his flying company. The twin brothers are mourning not only the death of their father, but their elder brother who died in war as well. Thus, Grayson, boggled down with grief amongst other issues, resorts to blackmailing Leah, forcing her to fly for Mr. Hall's his company and date his twin brother, Alec. Alec is most probably the most underdeveloped character in the novel and except for being a goody-two-shoes, there isn't much to him. On the other hand, I really liked the way Grayson's personality was built around his grief and it felt very realistic to me. Yet, for a novel marketed as being a contemporary romance, I was strangely unable to understand Grayson's romance with Leah.

Leah and Grayson have had a crush on each other ever since they first met because they are both oh-so-sexy. While they aren't aware of each other's crush, it is very obvious to the reader and thus, there's a large amount of sexual tension between these two but no real development of a relationship, let alone love. I didn't understand how Leah could still like Grayson, even after the blackmail and the fact that he thought she was a whore. Yes, Grayson - along with the rest of the town actually - thinks Leah is a whore. In fact, Grayson accused Leah of sleeping with his own father because Mr. Hall gave Leah free flying lessons and Grayson uses this life-long assumption - that had no basis whatsoever - to coerce her into dating his brother! But, this doesn't matter because Grayson is really hot and Leah still likes him a lot! I'll admit that Grayson did have quite a few scenes where he was genuinely sweet to Leah and it is obvious that Leah and Grayson truly understood each other, which is quite rare in a Young Adult Novel. Yet, it almost felt as if Leah had Stockholm Syndrome most of the time, except with a blackmailer instead of a kidnapper, and her feelings for Grayson were barely explained, except to re-iterate how hot Grayson was.

Echols' romance aside, what frustrated me the most was Leah. While I sympathized with Leah's situation of being poor, a bastard child, and mostly living on her own because her mother took off from time-to-time, I couldn't connect with or understand her actions. Leah is known as the neighborhood slut for being pretty. Yes, that's it! Sure, she dresses skankily and flirts, but that doesn't warrant a reputation like that. Furthermore, Leah does nothing to dispel the stereotype and I hate the manner she's portrayed in the story. Ladies, it is not okay for a guy to blackmail you because he thinks you're a whore. It is not okay for a guy to be pissed off at you for not having sex with him. It is not okay for men to have a pre-conceived notion about you based upon what you wear. It just isn't. One of my many teachers once told me that most women believe the reason they get raped is because they wear short dresses and revealing clothes, but that isn't true. You're allowed to wear what you want and nothing gives a man the right to think you want to sleep with him, to force himself on you, or to believe you're a whore based on your clothing. While Leah never gets raped in this story, I believe the allegory is very similar as the manner in which she is treated is just wrong and even by the end of the novel, that lesson is never learned. I wish Echols had either addressed this issue the way it needed to be spoken about in the novel or had at least changed her character if she didn't want to delve into such deep issues. Perhaps I'm reading too much into this, but the entire manner in which sexuality was looked upon in the story left my stomach rolling in a very bad way.

Such a Rush is a story that many readers will love, but I wasn't one of the them. I hated the underdeveloped romance and side characters and the themes this book exuded were way off the mark. Even Leah's rocky relationship with Molly, the rich girl who befriends Leah as a charity case, was confusing at best and didn't seem to have closure. Furthermore, this book was so dramatic and instead of a real discussion to solve the problems in this story, we get a predictable near-death experience to smooth things over - talk about a cop-out. Plus, I found the plot idea of a brother making decisions for his twin and blackmailing a childhood friend/sweetheart/acquaintance to be vastly unrealistic and just downright strange. I mean, Alec and Grayson are the same age! I understand Grayson's reasons for doing what he did in the novel and I really like his character, with the exception of the manner in which he treated Leah and how Leah still liked him despite all the crap he made her put up with, but at least Alec should have reacted remotely differently in this situation! I appreciate the dynamics between these two brothers, but the main ideas of this novel were simply too out there for me to grasp and connect with. Overall, I wouldn't recommend Such a Rush to people who are on the fence about Echols. If you're an avid fan, you'll most likely love this one, but me? I'm through - this is my last Echols novel for sure.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If you like Jennifer Echols and would like an opportunity to win a copy of this book, stay tuned till August 8th where you can enter for a chance to win this book and more during the Young Adult Giveaway Hop! :)

17 comments:

  1. Aw, I'm sorry you didn't enjoy this book! :( I'm gong to check out Forget You though as a lot of people, you included love that one. Thanks for the great and honest review!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're welcome, Zoe! Forget You was good, but I'd recommend starting with Going Too Far. It's her best book IMO!(:

      Delete
  2. Oh I'm so sorry this one didn't work out for you Keertana, I too had such high hoped for this with, the gorgeous cover and intriguing premise. But I understand not being able to connect with the character can be majorly off putting. Thanks for the honest review Keertana! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was quite disappointed I didn't enjoy this one either, Jasprit! I really hope you enjoy it more than I did though!(:

      Delete
  3. Hmm.. I'm pretty convinced now that this book isn't at all for me. The romance especially sounds frustrating. Although I do enjoy (love!) romance in my books, it has to be done right or left out all together. I doubt I would like the characters much either. :( Sorry this wasn't for you, Keertana, but thanks for taking one for the team! :) I wonder if I will ever get a Jennifer Echols read. :P

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Sam!(: Yup, Jennifer Echols just isn't the contemporary author for me. If you want to try her books, I'd recommend Going Too Far since it's her best one IMO, but I haven't enjoyed her other novels very much. I seem to prefer Sarah Dessen and Melina Marchetta! :P

      Delete
  4. Fantastic review, really. The only reason I haven't bought a copy of this is because I wasn't really sure if this was my cup of tea, but now? Um, no thanks. The romance does seem out of place and under-developed, and ... I didn't grasp the context of this book, even without reading it. It just doesn't make sense! o.O
    I'm sorry this wasn't for you, Keertana D: This book had such a huge hype surrounding it. I can only imagine the disappointment that it was!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Beatriz! Yes, this definitely was a major disappointment! I found the concept of the romance to be strange and difficult to grasp too, so this definitely wasn't my kind of book. Plus, the hype made me expect something really great and...it just didn't deliver. If you're looking for a good Echols read though, I'd recommend Going Too Far - it's my favorite of her books!(:

      Delete
  5. Oh, it's such a shame that this book is a disappointment for you, Keertana! I agree, it seems like a theory of blaming the victim because of things that happened to them. The romance doesn't sound like my kind - especially since Grayson accused Leah of doing something very horrifying! Well, maybe Leah is such a girl with big heart because she forgives him? x)


    Anyway, thank you for the awesome, honest review, Keertana! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Hilda!(: Leah definitely seems to have a huge heart, but I still wasn't a fan of their romance. Plus, the way she was portrayed was just...wrong IMO. I didn't enjoy this one, but I hope you have more success with it if you try it out! :D

      Delete
  6. Awwww, I'm really sorry that you didn't enjoy this book, Keertana! I haven't read this book yet but I am really dying to read it ever since I've read some reviews on the book. I absolutely loved Echols' previous books.

    Thank you for the honest and awesome review, Keertana! ♥

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Celine! I really hope you enjoy this one! If you liked Echols' previous novels I'm sure you will! :D

      Delete
  7. I can't say I'm warming much to Grayson, given his treatment of Leah in the book! But I do like that you say they actually understand one another. I can totally understand your issues regarding sexuality. I love that you get so involved, your passion really shines through, even though this isn't a gushing, all-praise review, it's... PASSIONATE. And that's what makes a good blogger :) But it always sucks when a book just doesn't hit the mark with you. I really want to try Jennifer's novels though, so I'll likely start with some of her previous ones!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Brodie!(: I lovee writing reviews and reading and I felt especially passionate about this novel, probably because there was so much hype about it and I just couldn't understand it. Plus, I feel very strongly about female sexuality and the way women are portrayed in literature, so I guess it came out in my review! ;) I'd definitely recommend starting with some of Echols' older novels though - Going Too Far is her best and Forget You is quite good too. I can't wait to see what you think of them! :)

      Delete
  8. Oh sorry this didn't work out for you Keertana! I am an avid Echols fan but her last couple of books left me disappointed. I did love this one though. My favorites like you are Going Too Far and Forget You. Nice honest review. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Rachel! I loved your review of this one and I'm so glad you were able to enjoy it! Unfortunately, I wasn't a fan of this one but Going Too Far was definitely extremely good, so I'm glad we both are able to agree on that count! :)

      Delete
  9. You have to buy it, it pulls you in from the very beginning!! You won't regret it , I promise you.

    Zaira Lynn (Divorce Lawyer)

    ReplyDelete

I love hearing from my readers and I read, reply, and appreciate every one of the comments I receive!(: If you're a fellow blogger, please leave a link to your blog - I'd love to drop by!

Unfortunately, this is now an award-free blog. I simply do not have the time to respond and forward on the award, but I truly appreciate the nomination regardless.