Saturday, March 9, 2013

Review: Will Grayson, Will Grayson by John Green and David Levithan


Title: Will Grayson, Will Grayson 

Authors: John Green and David Levithan

Rating: 4 Stars

what do i say about Will Grayson, Will Grayson that hasn't already been said before? on one hand, i am well aware that this novel has its fair share of flaws. i'll be the first to admit that john green writes very formulaic characters, from his dorky male single-child protagonist to the manic pixie dream girl he falls in love with. i'll also admit that the characters in Will Grayson, Will Grayson are often annoying, flawed, and highly irritating. its narrative style may grate on some readers, it is kind of hard to connect with at times, and the beginning is disastrously slow. yes, Will Grayson, Will Grayson has its flaws, i'll be the first to admit that, but it also has its own rare form of beauty, brilliance, and heart that in my eyes, more than makes up for any flaws that it might have.

Will Grayson, Will Grayson is the first novel i've read that has been narrated by two authors. it's also my first foray into the work of david levithan and i have to admit, i'm impressed. it's only my third john green novel and while i love his vlogbrothers videos, Looking for Alaska really didn't work me, despite my love for The Fault in Our Stars, so i was a little worried going into this. david levithan and john green have such distinct styles, though, and the combination of their two voices is just...magic. although john green's Will Grayson is distinguished by the capitalization in his narration, opposed to david levithan's will grayson whose narration reads much like this review (you wouldn't believe how hard it is not to use the "shift" key!), any distinguishing characteristics are completely unnecessary, simply because it would be impossible to get these two boys, who share the same name, mixed up.

Will Grayson, Will Grayson is your run-of-the-mill contemporary tale, but the night that Will Grayson meets will grayson, roughly a third of the way into the novel, their lives irrevocably change. Will Grayson is a nerdy, almost forgettable character who lives life not really caring by much. at first, Will Grayson seems rather bland and his narration is spiced up by jane, the girl he grows to appreciate and crush on, and tiny cooper, his best friend who is gay and really isn't tiny. at all. will grayson, on the other hand, is immediately a much more complex character than his counterpart. as a sarcastic adolescent who takes pills for depression, will fails to connect with the people in his life, with the exception of isaac, his online friend who will is actually in love with - and vice versa. will, however, has a girlfriend, maura, who he still hasn't come out to yet for reasons of his own and, needless to say, this causes quite a few difficulties in his life.

in all honesty, it's hard for me to put into words why Will Grayson, Will Grayson is such a fantastic novel. not only is it beautifully written, with profound statements dispersed between a very authentic teenage voice, but its ultimate message is incredibly moving. in some ways, this is less a novel about the two will graysons and more a novel about tiny cooper, the guy who keeps their lives connected. as i mentioned previously, Will Grayson, Will Grayson is not the kind of contemporary you immediately jump out and connect with. rather, what green and levithan attempt to do is convey the sense that although we all have difficult lives, many of us with problems that other people cannot even begin to understand, they are all real and problematic to us, no matter if there are starving children in africa with hiv/aids. while we cannot always reach out and understand others, we can appreciate them and what they do and that, sometimes, is more important than anything else.

in addition to conveying this beautifully, though, i loved the friendships throughout this story. first and foremost is the very complex, but sad, friendship between will grayson and maura. in all honesty, i'd love to see a sequel featuring her because, no matter how cruel her actions may have been, it is evident that she has a plethora of issues of her own to resort to such desperate methods in her life. most importantly, though, is the friendship between Will Grayson and tiny cooper, one filled with tiny lamenting over his ex-boyfriends as Will Grayson tags along. what neither of them understand is how important they are to one another and the realistic direction of their friendship, their gradual growing apart with time and coming back together with a deeper understanding, is the type of friendship we all experience, or want to experience.

just read Will Grayson, Will Grayson, okay? i know it has characters that can come across as incredibly selfish, but that's all part of their flawed charm. i know its characters may resemble other typical ones, but i promise you they all have one aspect of originality. i know it may seem as if you've read this story - the one about the gay couple, the one about friendship, the one about understand - before, but you haven't read it this way. you haven't read it written by these authors. although i had knocked off levithan's Every Day from my shelves, he's made me sure to pick up his other novels with this piece and john green? well, he always had my heart, but he'll have my money now too.

17 comments:

  1. Oh man. You're too persuasive for everyone's good, Keertana! I only read twenty-something pages of this when I had the ARC, because, for some reason, despite how much I admire these two authors separately (though neither are perfect), I just didn't find myself being interested in the two characters' lives. But, for some reason, I've held onto my copy of this book. It must be my subconscious telling me I need to give this another try!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was wondering why you weren't using capitals. ;) I can imagine how hard it must be not to press the shift key. It's pretty much an automatic response! I'm glad you enjoyed this book, Keertana. I haven't read anything by either of these authors before (I fail as a reader!) but I do plan to start my first John Green book this year. I like the sound of the storytelling here, with each author getting their own Will Grayson. I'm looking forward to experiencing it myself. :) Fantastic review!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Another beautiful review from you, Keertana. :) I can't even remember The Fault in Our Stars without feeling something break in my heart. And you made me laugh when you said that John Green made formulaic characters LOL. xD I'm very interested about this book, so I might pick it up someday. And just like you, I think I'm going to love it and its flawed characters. :') Thank you for the lovely review, hun! <3

    ReplyDelete
  4. Lovely review Keertana! I'm so glad you enjoyed Will Grayson Will Grayson! It was such a fun read. My only complaint was that the ending was anti-climactic. But that was it!

    Have a great weekend!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Another great review Keertana! I didn't like this one as much as you did - the flaws were a bit more noticeable for me than the good parts, but I'm glad that you enjoyed it and that you're capable of writing such a well-written review of it. I also loved TFiOS but not Looking for Alaska so it's cool that we have somewhat similar tastes. Once again, wonderful analysis and I'm sure many will be persuaded to pick this up if they haven't already!

    ReplyDelete
  6. TINY COOPER!! He is such a show stealer in this book. You nailed it when you said he really is the star of the show. I liked this book and the story of the two Will's, but larger than life Tiny is what I will always remember about it:) Great review!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am impressed with how you wrote this review to match the book! I keep hearing about this one, and how I need to read it, but I have yet to invest my time. I'm always interested when two well known, distinctive authors write together and make it work. Though I've noticed David Leviatham doing a lot of co-writing recently. Did you not like Every Day? Or not read it at all? I keep hearing good things about it, so I'm very interested in your opinion. Everyone raves about Tiny Cooper, clearly I need to meet him soon.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I was so distracted by your not using proper capitalization! Haha. This one didn't work for me until... Tiny Dancer. I loved Tiny so hard. This is the only John Green I've read and it didn't really compel me to seek out more, although I did buy Fault In Our Stars. God, I'm such a sheep!

    I've only read one other book with dual authors -- Joel and Cat Set the Story Straight by Nick Earls and Rebecca Sparrow -- and even though you were ambivalent about Nick McGowan, I still recommend Joel and Cat. :)

    -Maggie

    ReplyDelete
  9. To be perfectly honest, I'm not overly fond of David Levithan's books or his writing style. That's mostly whyI've been avoiding this. On the other hand, i do love and admire John Green and this is the only one of his books I have yet to read.

    It does sound interesting and the characters seem to be layered, so that's definitely a plus. I'm sorry I've been MIA lately. I burned my hand pretty badly and typing has been a challenge.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I've never read anything by David Levithan before Keertana, and I was kind of confused too about why you weren't using caps letters in your review, it is so tempting to use the shift key when I'm writing, but you've done a great job of getting the point across of exactly what Levithan's narration reads like, so thanks for the heads up. I think I will have to pick this book up along with the several other beautiful books you've recommended Keertana! Lovely review! :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Keertana, it's not even fair how you're so creative and persuasive! I can't even imagine how difficult it is to not use the Shift key, I mean, it's second nature to me now.

    But even with the numerous flaws this book seems to have, you've nonetheless convinced me I absolutely must pick this book up. The writing seems so gorgeous, and it's amazing that the authors could distinguish their two characters so flawlessly. Not only that, but the friendships and self-discovery sound ah-mazing as well.

    Well Keertana, you've done it again! I guess I'll be picking up a copy of this the next time I swing by the library. I swear, my TBR's massive growth can be attributed at least partially to you! ;) Thanks for such a beautiful review, as always. <3

    ReplyDelete
  12. *sigh* I have missed DEARLY reading your beautiful reviews, Keertana! I haven't read WILL GRAYSON, WILL GRAYSON, but from your thoughts in your review, it looks like I REALLY need to. I love your creativity in writing this review, by the way. :) I think Levithan and Green are talented in the way that they're able to make somewhat cliche characters, but make it original at the same time, and I'm so glad you were able to overlook the common storyline/plot. I can't wait to meet the side characters Tiny Cooper and Maura, because they seem like quite big side characters. Lovely, lovely review, Keertana!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I definitely wondered about the choice of review style at the start, but know it makes sense. I can imagine how difficult it was to write like that and I'm not sure if I would have been able to resist. Particularly when I like the look of capitals so much. I mean there is something so offensive looking to me about a little "i".

    However, I am definitely intrigued as to how the authors pull of the writing style and its workings.

    It definitely sounds like a book that has a lot to offer, from two authors that I've heard lots about. I'm so glad you managed to enjoy this one, Keertana even if you can't pinpoint exactly why.

    Fabulous review as always! :)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Looking for Alaska is my least favorite John Green book but I love him! I do agree that his characters a formulaic though. But I guess I dont mind. I love them. And the same with David Levithan. I will read everything they both write. So them together was magic. But I'm with you, this book isn't perfect, I had a few issues myself, but I still absolutely loved it. Fantastic review!

    ReplyDelete
  15. I have to admit, I've really been turned off of this book. I personally dislike 90% of the author collaborations I read, and I've strongly disliked those by Levithan before...I just don't think he's the author for me. On top of which, I do love John Green, but yes, his characters are pretty stock and that keeps me from jumping at all of his novels. I think you've made so many excellent points about digging under the surface of these characters and seeing the bigger story/message of the book, but I'm still not sure that I'll ever pick this one up.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I feel like I should give this another go, it was my first JG book and either my 1st of 3rd DL book, but I just thought it was ok, even after reading lots of +ve reviews. I am a fan of multiple authors writing books together, I think it's fun!

    ReplyDelete
  17. I keep putting off reading John Greene, and I don't know why. Partly because I keep seeing a variety of reviews, ranging from raves to "formulaic," per your review, and other such criticisms. I think I secretly fear the books will annoy me and I don't want to dislike them, hah.

    But wow, this one won you over! I've heard this is one of his better ones. It might be a better one for me to try than TFIOS. Nicely reviewed!

    ReplyDelete

I love hearing from my readers and I read, reply, and appreciate every one of the comments I receive!(: If you're a fellow blogger, please leave a link to your blog - I'd love to drop by!

Unfortunately, this is now an award-free blog. I simply do not have the time to respond and forward on the award, but I truly appreciate the nomination regardless.